Lesson 3: Payoff vs P&L
Promise: Stop making the #1 beginner error. Payoff ≠ Profit.
The Critical Distinction
In Lesson 2, you learned to identify whether an option is ITM or OTM. But being ITM doesn't mean you made money.
| Concept | What It Is | Formula |
|---|---|---|
| Payoff | Cash received at expiry | max(0, S - K) for calls |
| P&L | Payoff minus what you paid | Payoff - Premium |
An option can be ITM and still lose money. If your payoff is less than the premium you paid, you lost.
See It In Action
Drag the sliders to explore how payoff and P&L differ. Notice the orange "danger zone" between strike and breakeven.
The gray Payoff line shows what you receive at expiry. The blue P&L line shows your actual profit or loss after subtracting the premium you paid. The green BE marker is your breakeven price.
"P&L is payoff shifted down by the premium."
Breakeven Is Not Strike
Many beginners assume they profit once the option is ITM. Wrong. You profit when the payoff exceeds your premium.
| Position | Breakeven |
|---|---|
| Long Call | Strike + Premium |
| Long Put | Strike - Premium |
Example: You buy a $100k call for $5k premium. Your breakeven is $105k, not $100k.
If BTC settles at $103k, you're ITM but still down $2k.
"Breakeven is not strike."
The Three Scenarios
You bought a $100k call for $3k. Where does BTC settle?
The middle row is the trap. Positive payoff, negative P&L.
Max Loss and Max Gain
| Position | Max Loss | Max Gain |
|---|---|---|
| Long Call | Premium | Unlimited |
| Long Put | Premium | Strike - Premium |
| Short Call | Unlimited | Premium |
| Short Put | Strike - Premium | Premium |
For long options, max loss is always the premium. This is why options are attractive for defined-risk trading.
Common Mistakes
| Mistake | Correction |
|---|---|
| "I'm ITM, I'm winning" | ITM only means payoff > 0. P&L could still be negative. |
| "Max loss is the strike" | Max loss for longs is the premium, not the strike. |
| Ignoring breakeven | You don't profit until S exceeds breakeven, not strike. |
| Comparing payoff shapes without premium | Always compare P&L. Premium changes everything. |
💡 Tip: Try answering each question yourself before revealing the answer.
See Also
Navigation: ← Lesson 2: Calls, Puts, Moneyness | Lesson 4: Time Value →